Like everyone else who has played Red Dead first I'd give this game a solid 7.5.....and that's really because of subconsciously I compare the two every time I ride that motor sickle....if I'd played this first it would get an 8.5. Not much higher as there are some annoying tech goofs but I'm not persecuting Days Gone like some snobby butt lickers will and do. It IS a fun game to play just used to having variable distances to watch my character from.