Roberts: “Very nice coat. Remember, after mink comes sable”
A Jewish, New York City youth (Garfield) looking thirty-two yet still possessed of quick hands, a quicker temper, rejects the nickel and dime candy store world of his parents (Revere Smith) in flavor of a boxing career, mom and pop voting a split decision but unanimous approval from his pushy pal (Pevney) and artful girlfriend (Palmer) (“Tiger tiger“). A natural fighter, Charley’s rise is steady and swift, each victory bringing a bigger purse and thirst for “chunks of dough” in subsidy of his new, lavish lifestyle (Brooks) and concert with the criminal element who run the show (Gough). Not dishonest, money is his mojo, yet, taking the title soon has Davis “all mobbed-up.” As debts mount and punches take their toll, his marker gets called in, forcing the local hero to take a dive for the brash up n’ comer.
The commies nearly outnumber the capitalists in this one. John Garfield stars in his most famous, if not best role (Breaking), he one of seven (7) artists KO’d by the blacklist, four more actors (Revere Smith Gough Lee), its writer (Polonsky) and director, Robert Rossen. Runs long for the genre (1.75h), mostly in flashback, around midway I was hanging on the ropes, Joe Implausability giving my brain a beating. Sidekick Shorty is a fast shuffle who sells his boy to the local agent (Conrad) with zeal of a girl scout cookie hawk, yet, oddly turns Father Flanagan whenever Mr Reality pays a visit, while slugger’s best gal, Peg, starts supportive (“anything you want”), then too acts like she’s just off the turnip truck when the seedy side sprouts. And mom, she can’t really think her boy is clerk material or has a violin and Joan Crawford in his future. But like a ring judge, you’ve gotta go the distance before filling out your score card. Impressive are the first timers in credit: radio star Virginia Gregg is Peg’s sassy roommate who sculpts in all mediums: “Are you decent? Irma: Not particularly, bring him in!” Veronica Lake look-a-like Hazel Brooks will wow as the sultry hanger-on fronting as a club singer, and Lloyd Gough (Goff) is Roberts, smooth talking promoter who treats fighters like chattel and delivers the film’s best lines with an unsettling persuasiveness (“Everybody dies”).
All is captured by noted lensman James Wong Howe (Hud), most the punches landing late in prep for, and during the final bout, action that ranks with that seen in boxing greats The Set-Up (49), Killers Kiss (55), Fat City (72) and Raging Bull (80), De Niro (La Motta) displaying the same volatility and rapid-fire delivery as Garfield‘s Davis. Adding authenticity are the real life pugilists: Uly Williams, Larry Anzalone, Artie Dorrell is final foe Jack Marlowe, Ceferino Garcia (belt) (camp), giant slayer John Indrisano (referee) who coached John among others (Ryan Rooney Tracy Taylor MacMurray Montalbon Grant) and then credited black actor, Canada Lee whose champ-turned-trainer Ben gives a stylish performance on directness (“People don’t matter to you, do they, Mr Roberts?”) and sarcasm (Roberts: “Nobody’s gonna die; Ben: Thank you, Mr Roberts, thank you”). Nominated for three Oscars (actor play edit), cutters Lyons & Parrish taking home the hardware. To the ending, this might be Hollywood’s last dream before realism took firm, Everlasting hold (3★/4).