I finished the game once and moments after wanted to again the characters feels real they have a view on the world and are great
I also enjoyed the fact that the death of Arthur Morgan wasnt as you would expect for an outlaw but its more real for the time in the first game John dies from getting shot and you would think that would be the end of an outlaw but in Rdr2 Arthur dies in a way which is more common for the time and its sad but its better