First I want to point out something about most of the 1 star reviews. A lot of the people on there are mad about Disney being "woke" which hasn't been a new thing lately. Disney has been woke for a long time and I don't understand why you would take time to add a review for a movie you probably didn't watch anyway. Some of them are genuine reviews from people critizing the movie, you can tell they actually watched it and I respect those. You have a right to not like something, but actually watch it before making an opinion.
Now for what I thought. I am not a fan of the remakes and live actions. I knew this would be the same. I feel like disney should grow with their audience and make the movie more adult and change it up. But they are what they are so, we are taking it for what it is.
For what it is, it's probably one of the better live action movies. I can't say "not my favorite" i don't really have a favorite. I can see why they chose Halle to play Ariel. Her voice is amazing, and she gives off the princess vibes with how she acts and speaks as well. She can sing and that's no secret. Even if you don't like the movie, you would enjoy listening to her sing.
I loved the connection between her and eric. it seemed they were trying to improve it from the old movie and I will say as someone who critizes these movies hard, they actually did well with building that. They were honestly very cute together.
I loved some of the new songs they added. "Some" being the key word here. Halle does great with hers after she loses her voice. her facial expressions where subtle but effective.
Now, surprise suprise, I didn't like the CGI. Some of it was great, blending very well. Some of it....was very odd and off. It took me out of the movie at times. But since this is a kids movie, I'm sure they won't even notice. I did not like their pick for Triton. It more or less felt like he was reading off a script and I didn't feel much emotion from him. I did not like Scuttle. At all. Not being shes a girl. Idc about that. I didn't like the song. She was just annoying and not funny. Sebastian was great! I didn't hate him even though his design was cringe when they showed it.
All in all, I thought it was good. I actually thought about watching it again in theaters, which I would never do for live action. I am impressed with what they could do with this, but I still feel like they need to change it up more so people stop comparing it to the old movies and make them their own.