So after deciding that I wasn't going to buy this game because of the way Naughty Dog (a company whose games I have purchased since Way of the Warrior) treated people talking about the leaks on YouTube and the internet as a whole, it found its way to me via someone that wanted me to play for my opinion.
I am not someone that enjoyed the first game. I thought it was tedious, slow, a rip off of the film "Children of Men" but with mushroom zombies. I enjoyed the graphics but the gameplay was plodding and slow. I had no love for either character, though I understand the development of the relationship and appreciated how it was fleshed out through the story.
Here we are playing 2...
The graphics are very nice. Lighting and shadows look and react like they should. Textures are okay in some spots but do not hold up to scrutiny in much of the game.
Deaths happen and the violence is violent. There are multiple, drawn out, brutal sequences of killing involving dogs that is simply distasteful. It isn't clever or unique. It is disgusting and realistic. I don't give a damn that it is a video game, putting that in my head, making others have to experience it? Revolting.
The point of it isn't "well it is supposed to make you feel uncomfortable" that is a cheap excuse to put something vile in your hands and tell you to lick it so you know how vile it is.
The story makes little sense. If you set out on a quest for revenge and then fail miserably because... Why? Why, after killing dogs, horses, enumerous amounts of people, some of whom are pregnant women, do you just stop?
You fill your plate with all that darkness and then don't get the resolution to the story?
If Ellie is so hellbent on taking her revenge that she loses everything else in the process, why the hell doesn't she follow through!? It makes no sense at all.
This entire game is an exercise in futility. The developers thought they were saying something by exposing you to all the brutality but in the end, your desensitized, your aggravated, and your out $65.16.
Tl;DR As an outsider looking in, this game was a shameful, grossly violent slog that thinks your stupid and punishes you for playing it.