It gets 2 stars because I like Negan and Maggie.
Otherwise, I echo the sentiments of many I've seen here. The ample talents of JDM and LC are not enough to save what is a really bad concept, really bad writing, cringe-worthy dialogue, and nonsensical plot.
It's playing out like really bad TWD fan fiction.
I want to remember TWD as this perfect, once-in-a-lifetime show. I refuse to let this steal that from me, so I wont be watching any more.