As a standalone film, Superman is a triumph in casting. David Corenswet embodies (an albeit whiny) Superman in every way: his sincerity, naivety, hope, and belief in humanity shine through every scene. Rachel Brosnahan gives us a Lois Lane who’s no damsel—she’s a fierce, intelligent reporter who actively shapes the story, not just reacts to it. Nicholas Hoult’s Lex Luthor is truly chilling: calculated, bitter, and dangerously intelligent.
There are a lot of superheroes in this movie, but it makes sense—Clark is around 30 here and has been Superman for three years, so a wider world already exists. The question is whether these characters are given enough space, and I think, mostly, the answer is yes.
The Daily Planet characters are well done, especially Lois and Clark. Jimmy Olsen’s portrayal is different, but interesting. The so-called “Justice Gang” (a name from Guy Gardner—thankfully not likely to stick) is handled well for their screentime. Green Lantern and Mr. Terrific were excellent additions. Hawkgirl left me wanting more, which is a good thing—she’s being set up well for future development. I’m hoping we get a solo project that does justice to her rich lore.
Metamorpho could’ve used more development—he plays his role, but feels a bit undercooked. Since he’s a more niche character, I doubt we’ll see a solo project, which makes this missed opportunity more noticeable.
The Engineer, however, is where the movie slips into “tell, don’t show.” Only two lines explain her origin and motives, which isn’t enough. On the other hand, Ultraman could be seen as Gunn's way of telling us that the Multiverse does exist, but he's avoiding it (probably in response to Marvel’s multiverse fatigue). I don’t think the multiverse ruined the MCU—it was how they handled it. So I’d welcome DC’s version done right, and it is a huge part of the lore, but the DCU can work without a Foerever Evil movie at the very least.
Lex’s motivations: perfectly portrayed if you catch one particular conversation. Otherwise, they might not be clear to everyone. His hatred for Superman—rooted in jealousy, fear of alien superiority, and pure ego—is present in his words and actions. But many viewers I spoke to didn’t pick up on it. Gunn does well to keep it subtle, but I’d argue slightly more overt storytelling wouldn’t hurt for broader clarity.
My biggest issue? The science. As someone who studies physics, it pulled me out. Yes, it’s science fiction, but Lex is using Earth tech. What he creates goes far beyond any justified leap. Had he studied Kryptonian tech or the Phantom Zone projector, maybe, but there's no setup and unfortunately a terrible explanation I'd have been better off without. It just goes too far. Still, Marvel's done worse thus far.
Overall, this was a decent, experimental start to the new DCU with Gunn's promise of no origins and younger, more inexperienced characters.