First off. The location was BEAUTIFUL. Cars, costumes, look of the movie were amazing.
The movie itself was mediocre. Script was “fine” but the direction felt disjointed. The vibe of the movie was indecisive that the acting suffered that there was no chemistry between the leads. Scenes were either rushed that character development suffered, or they were milked to pointlessness (like the guy playing an entire ukelele singing sequence). Really bad directing and editing.
Sadly, Colin Firth was trapped in this really badly directed movie that he failed to fully shine through except for maybe a couple of scenes. You see glimpses of his brilliance near the end of the movie with his conversation/interaction with her aunt. Both actors in that were pretty good despite the “average” writing. And watching a groveling Colin Firth in the awkward proposal scene was one of the very few bright spots.
The movie just lunged into too many directions that it had no identity....even trying to imitate the ending of “My Fair Lady”. If the intent was to modernize that movie with a early 1900’s version, then you will see no hint of it throughout the movie except the ending. I wanted to like it, but I can’t.