Just watched Season 2; I LOVE this show.
I'm not sure why; not a SciFi fan (which this has been categorized as), nor a "Western" or "Rich Man, Poor Man" type fan (although big Yellowstone fan), but this show has me hooked. I'm so ready for Season 3!
Nothing actually sets this apart (except the excellent soundtrack choices), imo, but it has just enough of everything interesting, frightening, weird, scenic, historic, and just plain funny ("Acting" Sheriff Joy: "I hate to tell you this but Michael Jackson was the biggest pop-star in the world." [or something along that line]) to keep us watching, and now, again, waiting for next season.
Recommend watch from S1E1 through all available when possible to truly appreciate the story lines and just plain weirdness.