Atul Kumar

Seriously? What the f**k was that? Out of the 3 retellings, I watched the first, fast-forwarded the second, and skipped the third. I don't know who greenlights these movies and how people make money out of these movies.

There are some movies you watch in the theater, and when you come home, you keep thinking about the events that left an impression. With this movie, I can’t recall anything worth remembering. Apart from one character, there was no real character development. Why are they conducting the walk? Why were these guys chosen to participate? Why weren’t there any girls in the walk? People started dying, and after a point, it just became the expected outcome. The characters weren’t developed enough for the audience to actually care about their deaths. Only one character was given a proper background story, and it was obvious he wasn’t going to survive. The movie clearly wanted me to care for him, but it was so predictable that he would die in the end. On top of that, I don’t think the movie accurately portrayed what would actually happen if you walked at 3 mph for 3–4 days continuously. P.S. The story could have been more engaging if there were milestone-based incentives—for example, limited first-come-first-serve rewards like better shoes, food, or bathroom access.

Didn’t see the point of the whole thing. Had the story been presented in a linear way, would flopped for sure.

I don’t understand the point of this movie. When I started watching it, I thought it would be a great story about the American Dream. I assumed it was based on a real-life event, which made me optimistic. But it turned out to be just a movie about victimhood—the story is written that way. The protagonist survives the Holocaust, comes to the U.S., gets an opportunity but is accused of making a pass, gets another opportunity but faces opposition from everyone, and eventually suffers physical violence. It felt like the writer was deliberately manufacturing trauma and obstacles for the protagonist rather than letting them unfold naturally. The acting and cinematography are good, but they are tainted by the story. The movie spends three hours building towards something that never materializes, only to be stamped as a symbol of Holocaust survival—something that was never even meaningfully explored in the film.

It was supposed to be a good film. It isn't. I would say that the conceptual story is good but the execution is illogical. mature direction and screenplay would have helped. but in India, we don't take feedback. We think that the audience is stupid and they will watch anything. it's sheer laziness on the creator's part. wake up. the audience has. if u have a good story, don't ruin it with bad execution.

One of the best movies ever. Took me on a journey. Witnessed a slow transition from an innocent yet determined teenager to a brave heart. A person who always did what he promised. Loved with all his heart. Fought with all his strength. Gave everything that was on offer and never backed away from responsibilities and promises. Did all this in his short 25-year life. He died at my age. It's a film about a filmy guy who left his people too early, yet his life seems complete. Don't miss this. Watch it in your own sweet time but watch it and remember him for all he was, a son, a lover, a soldier and a brave heart.

Hollywood has become narcissist in their approach of film making. Nowadays, most of the short budget movies that i watch, there is no ultimate result. Movie starts on a positive note and just subsides into negativity. It never redeems itself. It never has a positive conclusion. This is the case with this movie. We invest ourselves in these characters and nothing happens at the end. They just die. I was watching "The Rental" yesterday. Same thing. Everyone dies. I don't know why people will turn up to watch these kind of movies. These movies just remind us of our linear pathetic life. That's not why we watch movies. We watch movies for hope, refuse and satisfaction. Something that has been completely forgotten in movie making nowadays. If you are depressed or sad or alone, don't watch these kind of movies. You will save time and avoid negativity.

worst movie ever seen. -100 stars if possible. waste of resource and talent. No meaning to the movie. How studios allocate money to these awful scripts, i can't fathom.

Movie is good with some bad performances. Specially Zoe family.

Was having initial difficulty of understanding the timeline of the story but once it revealed itself, though slowly, it was a blast. Very engaging. The Garald is that character that you want to see on the screen all the time, just like John snow. The atmosphere of the show is very authentic but confusing. It was difficult to understand who was fighting who. A explainatory map would have helped like the one in the game of thrones. Problem with binge watching, it gets finished quickly and we have to wait for another whole year for the next season.