Weapons is a crap one for me. On the surface, it has everything going for it โ a solid cast, a creepy and ambitious premise, and moments that are funny or well-executed. The acting is actually really strong across the board, and thereโs clearly an attempt to do something different and โdeep.โ But in the end, it doesnโt land the way it should, and it definitely doesnโt have the staying power or craft of someone like John Carpenter, Wes Craven, fuck me, not even Robert Wiene.
The main issue is that the film feels more like a showcase for performances than actual storytelling. Instead of drawing me into the characters and the horror, it kept bouncing between styles and perspectives that looked interesting but didnโt give me much to hold onto emotionally. The structure โ different chapters from different points of view โ sounds clever, but a lot of it felt hollow, like it was trying too hard to be stylish rather than making me actually care.
Even when the actors do a great job, the characters themselves donโt really stick. I never felt truly invested in them, which makes the film come across cold and detached. And when the big reveal finally comes โ with the witchcraft angle โ it felt messy, under-explained, and nowhere near worth all the buildup. Instead of being scary or satisfying, it felt silly and left me disappointed. Thatโs not to say all horror has to be scary, but at least all horror can be designed to make you think! Leave a lasting impression, stand out for all sorts of reason. For instance, The Kurt Russels, The Thing, stood out for its amazing craft of old school prosthetics and special affects and created a chilling atmosphere from that alone! This film does not leave you with questions that makes you crave more. It doesnโt reward you for sitting there for almost 2 hours taking in the build-up. Instead we have a gag at the end and that just made me feel personally empty, and disappointed because itโs been done before.
By the final act, the tone is all over the place. It flips into dark comedy and absurdity at points where the film shouldโve doubled down on horror. That shift completely undercut the tension, and I left feeling like the film wanted to be more than one thing but didnโt commit to any of them properly.
In short:
Yes, there are great performances and a cool concept buried in here, but as a horror film it doesnโt work. It prioritises actors and moments over real storytelling, and for me that makes it fall flat. I donโt want โperformances and bullshitโ when I sit down to watch horror โ I want something with proper weight, atmosphere, and story. Weapons just doesnโt deliver that.