Carrie Young

I really love this show! It is so fascinating to watch all the creations come to life and hear the amazing stories of each contestant. I do, however, have to say how disappointed I am after the 2nd episode of Season 3. It is very frustrating to see the criteria and the categories the contestants will be judged on, then see the judges sending someone home who met all the criteria, and leaving others in who did not meet all the criteria. You say all they will be judged on, then you don't refer much to that when you're all talking about each one. You seem to base it off of personal preference. PLEASE consider having the judges walk around with a sheet to rate each contestant's work based off of the criteria, so we don't ultimately get judges preference of what they like over what the contestants have done to meet the criteria. This way, it is on a point system which will make it much easier for the judges and WAY more fair for the contestants. I am EXTREMELY disappointed with who got sent home in this episode because of this. I mean, I never like to see anyone get sent home, but this made absolutely NO sense and now I'm reluctant to finish watching Season 3 if that is how the judges continue to decide. Please bring that contestant back for Season 4. I was really looking forward to seeing that person's work!!