Is The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, really as bad as they say?
The main flaw if this episodic adventure is the absorption of the Holy Grail of Elven Lore, into its title; The Lord of the Rings. The desire to try and connect with diehard Lord of the Rings fans through a fable so dissimilar from the original Tolkien masterpiece or the Peter Jackson, cinematic adaptation, was a recipe for disaster.
I could say I have an open mind to the potential of a new prospect, gurgling away within this witch's caldron known as "The Rings of Power", but truth be told, I am a fan, but not a diehard fanatic of The Lord of the Rings trilogy. I can however, understand the rage and frustration of Tolkien fans, who feel betrayed by this adaptation which rewrites the Lord of the Rings canon.
With regards to; The Rings of Power, what I can honestly say, as I observed the pilot episodes, at no time was I reminded of The Lord of the Rings trilogy, I was however, submerged by flashback memories of another Elven fable, the Disney epic fantasy; "Willow". There are so many similar traits with the Disney film, which made me wonder, why didn't the producers of R.O.P. target the Disney franchise and more importantly, the Disney fandom instead.
Rings of Power, has a slow pace. It is similar to a soap opera at times but so is Willow. R.O.P. Does not take itself too seriously, it prefers a gentle slope to a treacherous mountain. Rings of Power is light handed with violence and gore. It keenly searches for humor and a break from disparity. It chooses to avoid dwelling within the horror aspect of it's genre. Instead, it focuses on primitive inspiration; a glimmer of light, a gentle smile, a bit of tongue-in-cheek humor, the occasional laugh and the sublime power of friendship. In essence, the original Lord of the Rings Trilogy was excessively contrite throughout the entire saga, which of course worked favorably for the closing scenes, when peace and tranquility was fiiinally-- restored.
Honestly, I must admit, I was actually expecting a far worse introduction to this series, Yes I believe they could tone down the CGI and also allow the performers to showcase their characters with greater freedom without attempting to live up to the expectations of their namesake inspiration.
Galadriel is a beautiful girl, she is the face, the go-to girl of the series and I believe she has allot of potential but she is no Cate Blanchet. That is not to say she could not hope to be her own Elven princess, no, on the contrary, I believe she can but I would remind her, according to the timeline, she is far younger (in elf years) than her predecessor from the Lord of The Rings. She should really allow her youthful inexperience to shine through instead of attempting to portray an unearned image of wisdom. All in all R.O.P can be a hit, if the viewers are willing to look beyond The Lord of the Rings and accept the series as a standalone saga.