I really love appreciate the story at first I just judge Lily Bloom &Ryle Kincaid from it ends with us and was really upset and even wrote an stupid review and Lily Bloom & Ryle Kincaid and curse them but after I read it starts with us I really love it . But I still think Lily Bloom was a little too naive that she chose Ryle Kincaid to marry but it's ok she is an human and human makes mistakes. But I'm really happy that Atlas Corrigan got what he deserves. Atlas Corrigan has loved Lily Bloom all his life and Atlas Corrigan deserves Lily Bloom and she deserves him . I read it starts with us within 1 day and it's the best book I have ever read "Colleen Hoover" is an amazing author and going to start her another book called " Ugly love" hope it's going to be as amazing as this one. Love from Bangladesh too Colleen Hoover