I thought it was a good story w/ good acting (Clooney as a man with a terminal illness is perfection.) But, I couldn’t help be jarred by some of the unrealistic things in the movie ... first, scenes in the outdoor arctic. I just kept saying “no way” until I was ruining it for myself. And the “Sweet Caroline” while undertaking a serious outside the spaceship maneuver that their very lives depended on...that’s where I just was pulled out of the story, instead of being pulled into it. So, given that I sit down to watch a movie to be pulled into it and out of my own world, this didn’t do that.