It has the beginnings of a good game. Has potential but feels unfinished. 20 hours in so far. The Bad. Graphics are lackluster for a PS5 game. Some repetitive nature to it. Doesn't fully capture the feel of a HP series story. Not enough side quests. Could have done a lot more. Quittich, Beast training, multi-player, House cup, etc. The story is just ok.
The Good: good foundation for a game. Story is Ok. Some aspects are fun. Even with the limited number of equippable spells there is a lot to do and combine.
This is a decent play and I would put it as a middle tear game. Worth playing, but I would wait a few months and get it at a rebated price.