This is a general review on Yogananda/YSS/SRF. I believe we all find a Guru who is as authentic as our desire for the God is. While google is the only source these days for any true seeker, I am writing my opinion on this matter so that is something on the internet that can be found by a seeker. Yogananda is a great introduction to kriya yoga, but he doesn't teach the real kriya. I think even he has said his kriya is watered down for western audiences. Yogananda always wanted to become like Swami Vivekananda - which is why his organisation, the way he appears, what he talks draws heavy inspiration from him. And also why he never mentions him anywhere.Â
On the book: Yogananda had to make quite a few iterations to the original script to be able to find anyone to publish it. The end result you see today has a lot of 'magic' added to the book. Sri M in a talk available on youtube compares it to harry potter (search for Talk by Sri M ‘Purpose of Human Life and Ways and Means to Achieve It’ - at the 55 minute mark). Sri M's opinion carries more weight than mine anyway.
It is also said when he visited Panchanan Bhattacharya (the only person Lahiri Baba authorised for further initiations) for his interview, he was asked to leave pronto. His one or two line mention of Panchanan Bhattacharya proves this. Same with Tota puri maharaj, despite Yogananda visiting Puri many a time.
The drawing of "Mahavatar" Babaji (by the way no one in any of the lineages calls him Maha-avtar), published in his book made its way mischievously. He took one of the paintings his brother made of one of the queens/princesses available in the Calcutta library, gave it a bit of a male touch and called it Mahavatar Babaji. I think there was a bit of an argument on this between his brother and himself. No other authentic lineage of Lahiri Baba uses this image of Babaji.Â
Stones.Â
A person who is peddling kriya, is also peddling stones as a means for people to live a better life! How can a true devotee of God ask anyone to take any other refuge other than His?Â
Burn karma:It is impossible to burn karma. By a true Guru's grace only the intensity can be altered, that too is done in extreme cases. Most Gurus, while they can and sometimes do, do not interfere in His way of running the world. The example he himself gives where Babaji burns one of his devotees with a slight fire, is a direct example of this. How he says kriya burns karma is fascinating and another spice of magic in the book. A slightly scientific bent of mind might argue, how is kriya able to identify only bad karma to be burnt?Â
Take this book as a good intro to kriya and perhaps a few stories about Yogananda, nothing more. Many true masters exist even today. But as said by many, they are mostly hidden in the real world. Only your true and deep desire for God can lead you to them. Getting real kriya is a blessing. I have heard Yogananda represents the sales department. The real product lies elsewhere. Every advertisement is attractive.
I am also aware of the responsibility on my shoulders for writing this which is why I have taken great pains in finding all this information from authentic sources.