Not my usual type of game, yet after 49 hours of gameplay so far on a single campaign, I am hungry for more. I am averaging a couple hours at a time playing this game and I can't get enough of it. Rockstar games earned their name this time.
The graphics, the attention to even the smallest details. The character development, interactions, and even the well thought out personal character arcs present throughout the game are mind blowing. I have found myself just wandering around just seeing what kind of new and awesome things are waiting for me to find them. Not just missions or activities either. From stumbling across an abandoned shack filled with the decomposed bodies of a cult, and reading their papers. To being randomly attacked from nowhere by a cougar, the details this game has are beyond compare.
Bullet holes stay where they are, whether it's a cut scene after the battle, or it's days later and you ride back to the same place. Bodies don't disappear either, instead they decompose and are scavenged by predators. The game offers a chance to learn how to fish, but that doesn't mean you can't get fish before that, you can shoot the fish instead. So many ways that you can personalize the journey in this game.
I cannot give it too many stars.