Start with the good. Been a FLOYD fan for as long as I can remember. I have always appreciated each member of Floyd and what they brought to the table. And that's the point. Yes, some may have brought more. But nonetheless when they were all in their prime. They all contributed. I'm trying to be... "reasonable"... but this is nothing short of a monstrosity. They're will be fans who will like it. And it hasn't been lost on me that this is a "redux". But let's look at the original more closely and compare the two. Which no matter what anyone says, everyone is still going to do. The original whole album is the epitome of concept albums. It is the very best. No part of the album is weak. All the tracks are fantastic. So I'm not trying to do a disservice if I was to highlight certain moments on the album. But to take "On The Run" 8 note sequence synthesiser and have it as background noise whilst you talk over it Roger. Or to completely eradicate Nick Mason's drum solo on "Time". Perhaps one of the most recognised drums solos of all time. If not the most, and then. Then you have the audacity to completely delete Richard Wright's and Clare Torry's Great Gig In The Sky. People are quick to say Roger wrote most of Floyd's music. Newsflash! He didn't write this track. This just shows a total lack of respect! And don't even get me started on David Gilmour's guitar solos. Or the fact that not at the lack of them. But that there are NONE. Not one. Like I said at the beginning. I love all the band. But Roger, This just shows who you really are. I try to stay out of the politics side of things. But this just screams of the arrogant, egotistical, narcissist that you are!!! No matter what you do to try to rewrite history the bottom line is PINK FLOYD consisted of 5 members. Not just you. And music isn't just about writing songs. It is about composing, arranging, etc, etc, and the fact is, like I said, when you were all in your prime you all brought something to the table. The fact that you have completely deleted the other band members from one of the finest pieces of art of the 20th century just shows your complete lack of respect and to me is a fxck you not just to the other members of the band, but to us, the fans - I'm Roger Waters and I'll do whatever the fxck I want to do!!! Another Newsflash incoming Roger. Roger Waters will never be as big as what PINK FLOYD once was... Enough said.