Read all three book after watch my fault movie.
What I felt is yes Noah did wrong but that doesn't make any difference when he started sleeping with so many ladies after that and coming back just blame her. Spoiler* I hated it when he was planning to be with Sophia after Noah begging her life out to be with him. They would have never get back together if she didn't get pregnant, which made me sad about Nick. What was the use of him loving her so much and suffering with memories even after break up when he could have forgiven her. All my imagination while reading book was Nichole and Gabriel🥺🤌