I thought the movie was unique, interesting and entertaining the first time I saw it. Then after reading all of the various analyses of Us' reflection on class and socioeconomic politics, I had to see it again. The second time around I totally fell in love with the movie. Once you know the twist and why it's all happening, you can find all the symbols, easter eggs, very subtle nuances, etc., that are plentiful in the movie.
If you prefer straightforward storytelling, you'll like Get Out more. If you prefer inventive, ambitious films that lean toward artistry and depth, you'll like Us more. 9.5/10 from me.