Im giving the game 5 stars because it deserves it. Story wise. Gameplay wise, fighting, fishing. Its all fun. My only complaints are that the games side quests arent that fun. Although it cool too see familar faces all of the side quests feel rushed an unnecessary. Also about 99% of the time the side quest is practically "HEY!!. I need these items. Can you grab them for me?" When then forces you to go back an forth between certain unlocked areas. Other than that the games amazing. Just make sure to upgrade your characters. Use the training menu. Upgrade their know how an all that. Change out their palletes and make sure to do your soul icons an fill up those community boards. Otherwise your gonna have a real hard time.