The ending of the book felt kinda of rushed, and to say it's boring is even an understatement. Had little to no character development and the relationship between atlas and Lily had very little conversations, mostly just letters. Speaking of Atlas, the guy is simply too good to be real. He's completely devoid of flaws which just makes the book more boring. Also, although we all know Ryle doesn't deserve lily, Ryle couldn't have been portrayed like he's capable of hurting Rylee or Emerson. And the fact that his sister also thinks he's capable of doing such to the kids makes it all the more fake. I mean come on, that was a little bit too much. Essentially Collen Hoover couldn't have gone ahead with writing a sequel. Trust me it's not half as good as it ends with us.