To me Ishq is lawlessness accompanied by bigoted and narrow minded public perceptions about healthy societal relationships and it's inevitable prognosis towards anarchydom.
To me Ishq illustrates accurately, how the dices continue to be heavily loaded against women and all those people who genuinely care for HER and how they are vulnerable and collectively exploited, violently outraged and ruthlessly judged by a society infested by perverts. All this happen, notwithstanding so many (unenforceable) laws that are intended to secure and protect a woman's modesty and citizens fundamental rights in general.
A natural fall out of lawlessness in any democracy is the prevalence of one unwritten "law" : "Might is right!" Women and those men who keenly fight for their well being, safety or modesty (their male friends, husband, brothers, father amongst others) jointly and equally bear and share the brunt of such systemic tyranny.
In my humble view, Ishq is not really about toxic masculinity or about how men are raised and how they see the world, and manner in which men need to see themselves in order to presumably survive as men.
Ishq transposed me to those terrible times and similar situations in my life that are all too familiar; where I was forced to believe that there is no right move, and consequences are severely onerous; akin to a rigged contest where in the words of Abba, "the winner takes it all , and the loser stands to fall."
The characters in Ishq are good-natured lovers with a clear thought and intent to marry in the near future and how they become a prey to the worst kind of moral policing by pervs.
This is not one of those typical Indian films that begin with a woman's sexual assault and end with a man's satisfying thirst for revenge. Here, both parties equally suffer (in their own way). What is the kind of justice you can seek against rogues (these days) where there is total lawlessness?? .At no point did I feel this style of pursuit of justice to be a typical instance of "two wrongs making a right".
A man's pursuit of justice in present times, can be misconstrued easily by women who tend to operate well in the grey and are ready and willing to compromise under the popular adage "be ready to lose a battle to win a war".
In my view, Men need to get it into their thicker skulls that liberated woman hardly belong to anyone much less any man? The writing on the wall is clear. Don't try too hard to secure or protect such a woman. To those liberated women who don't care about the men who worry for them and try and fend and protect them. Don't worry! Chivalry is dead! Stay safe 🙏 and count your blessings.