The Patrick Star Show clearly epitomizes everything you shouldn’t do when making an animated series in general. Regardless if Stephen Hillenburg never wanted spin-offs, this show is still just as terrible.
Right off the bat this is a spin-off series based off the comic relief character of SpongeBob SquarePants. Lovable idiot spin-offs tend to fail due to the fact that the character is only meant to make a funny joke, usually implying something dumb off to the side throughout the series. Making an entire show with this type of character as the main role becomes uninteresting and even painfully unfunny fast. In terms of Patrick Star himself his personality is just as braindead as he is in the modern episodes of SpongeBob SquarePants. He doesn’t do anything funny or interesting, he’s just obnoxiously dumb for no reason. Not to mention, this show still uses the majority of the main characters from the original SpongeBob series which defeats the point of a spin-off. Everyone in Patrick’s “family” are also annoying as hell and have no character at all, and the writers completely destroy continuity with Patrick’s real parents and his sister Sam from the original series with an entirely different starfish family with an adopted squid sister Squidina who appeared in the modern episodes of the original show. I know Vincent Waller stated that they would be too boring to bring into the show but it still doesn’t make any sense and they all just act the same, so this doesn’t get their point anywhere.
Nickelodeon also announced that this series would have no rules, and this type of premise is honestly one of the worst influences I’ve ever heard of in the animation industry. Patrick can basically do whatever he wants in a universe where anything can happen. To me it’s just an illogical excuse for the writers to not even try to make this work. All that really happens is Patrick being a dingus who constantly bounces off the walls for 11 minutes in each episode. This show painfully tries to execute itself with crazy visuals and the loud and random equals hilarious shtick. It doesn’t work in the slighest and just makes this show even more unwatchable.
The animation is also just as bad as the modern episodes of the original SpongeBob series. The characters in this show just have to show overly exaggerated expressions every second, like when is the animation director going to realize that this is not Ren and Stimpy? The modern animation style was already despised and they decide to continue it here as well. Even the voice acting is terrible, everyone for some stupid reason has to obnoxiously shout their dialogue and I honestly feel sorry for all the voice actors that were hauled into this show like Bill Faggerbakke, Jill Talley, Tom Kenny, and Roger Bumpass especially when Nickelodeon made them talk about this show on camera on their social media.
If you are an aspiring cartoon creator, please don’t ever let Nickelodeon get their hands on your creation, because this is exactly what will happen if you let their executives take it over. Seriously, do not sell your production to Nickelodeon Animation Studios. They massacre every good show that they’ve worked with. This show says it all.