Honestly, for the first season I was super excited. I have grown up the games, since my dad introduced them to me, and I really am into the story, weapons, characters and everything else.the newer games 4-infinite weren't really as good as CE - Reach. When the sho came out I was disappointed in the story, but the very few action scenes were incredible. Yet I still had hope for the new season. I haven't watched it yet, but I still have some hopes. I understand everything with the helment and stuff, but I am more annoyed with the actual story, witch didt really go anywhere... Either way, I would say the show is decent. Definitely not a 5, and I wish you could rate like with points, but I would give it a 3.9, at least for the first season.i guess that would be a 4. Either way it is up to your opinions, but the games will always be better. I also think the games would be a 5 or above... The first 5 anyway