May creates an utterly unique experience, starting with a vague crime, a probable hit and a childhood friend called to rescue his wild eyed buddy. What’s most extraordinary is how over the course of a predominantly 2 man situation..we come to know Nicky more than Mikey. In a gradual reveal, we come to loathe him -quite rare in any film. And most astonishing, we wish him to be murdered!
The semi-improvised dialogue is both an authentic place between these guys (Philadelphia is not much there) but also makes some scenes unappealing.
Too bad Elaine May’s quirky genius, her determined pursuit of a character’s transformative journey kept her films from being the slick & finished product studios value. Messy true & original.