Very good but not great, especially in comparison to Lin-Manuel Miranda’s In the Heights, a far more effective musical film dedicated to the Puerto Rican experience in New York.
That said, there is much to appreciate in Steven Spielberg’s remake of West Side Story, including the brooding sets depicting a West Side in the throes of urban renewal, superb cinematography and excellent performances by Ariana DeBose (Anita), Rita Moreno (the shopkeeper Valentina, a new character created for the film), David Alvarez (Bernardo), Mike Faist (Riff) and Ansel Elgort (Tony.)
Spielberg depicts the Puerto Rican community sympathetically: his Sharks appear to have banded together for mutual protection against the racially-motivated aggression of the Jets. The Jets, by contrast, are portrayed as narrow-minded and resentful Whites intent on protecting their shrinking turf against the twin evils of racial change and urban redevelopment.
Spielberg’s decision to starkly contrast the Sharks (sympathetic) and the Jets (thugs) is justified in order to reconsider and redress the previous Broadway and film portrayal of the Sharks as “other.” A far better choice, however, would have been to inject similar humanity into the portrayal of the Jets. The tragedy of youthful gang warfare would be further underscored by depicting all combatants as vulnerable, rather than casting one side as heroic and the other as villainous.
The stereotypical portrayal of the Jets underscores the occasionally stilted quality of Spielberg’s West Side Story. Until the last quarter of the movie, the character of Maria is written as a bland Hollywood ingenue, depressing audience interest. The staging, while largely impressive, frequently emphasizes that the film was shot on a soundstage. These shortcomings reduce the immediacy and impact of the new West Side Story, detracting from the film’s many virtues.