2 star only because there are some admittedly beautiful scenic shots. Storywise the game is a mess. Graphically the game is good looking, though definitely not groundbreaking in anyway. Gameplay isn't terrible, it's essentially a carbon copy of TLOU1. It plays just like it with a jump, prone and simplified combat. The facial animations can look good but the transition between them during gameplay fall flat. Example, Ellie shows the struggle in her face during stealth kills but the transition into it & out of it is terrible. Definitely not the best PS4 AAA game released this generation. I put it well behind HZD, God of War, UC4, Days Gone. None of the new characters are likable in anyway, good or bad. Ellie is still a great character and an improvement over the first though.