10/10 visuals
9/10 gameplay
8/10 story
I agree with the majority of the fans that the story is where this game is lacking, but I disagree with the specifics. This game isn't The Last of Us Part 1, we knew going in that this was going to be a different game. Look at the cover, this is not a story about hope. There are a few cliches I wish they didn't do, but just because a character does something you don't like doesn't mean they are written badly. Not all characters are supposed to be empathized with.
I felt angry in this game at times. I felt sad, I felt sick, tired, and was left feeling hopeless at times. I think the fact that the game left me with such strong emotions is what makes it a good game.