Tell you what..
I like TLOU, I really do. Good story, and all, got us feel so attached to the characters. I enjoyed every seconds of it, like the mechanics. But then, Joel, the reason we love TLOU died to some new character we don't even know, the one that survive rebar stick through his chest, the one that killed every armed people in the hospital. Died to a golf club?! I rather have the generic story of died as a hero protecting Ellie from Clickers, but this?! Are you serious? Yeah, I get it this one is about revenge, but really?
Also, this "game" is more like an interactive movie, we couldn't choose the ending we want, might as well make it a movie.
I don't know how you can redeem yourself, ND