Shane McMannis

First off the gameplay and graphics are amazing. Playing this game is enjoyable if all you care about is that. As of the story naughty dog really dropped the ball on it, very terrible. The way they treated Joel is very criminal. Many if not all wanted to enjoy some playing time of our favorite character Joel. And they robbed that from us just wrong, all to push the strong independent women agenda. Then you have to play as the villain that killed our beloved Joel, not a good idea not really enjoyable. And the ending is even worse. We don't even get the sweet revenge of killing the killer of Joel very unsatisfying. So gameplay 5/5, graphics 5/5, storyline 0.5/5.