The first line should say it all: This was not what I was expecting.
Honestly, for a game marketed as "capable of redefining and revolutionizing the open-world RPG genre," it's not really living up to its name.
I preordered before launch, got the game downloaded, and booted it up for the first mere hours after it came out. It started fine, I never experienced a crash throughout the game (which is apparently quite lucky), and the intro was smooth. Everything after that, though, was just... I guess "meh" is the best way to put it.
Look, I'm not one of the people who believed this game would solve all their worldly problems, and I didn't worship CDPR or Cyberpunk 2077 before it came out, either. I was a skeptical buyer, and up until the release, I was decently sated with the stuff we had been shown. I didn't preorder the game until a week before the release. I wasn't as invested as some people were.
However, even then I was still disappointed. This game was supposed to "revolutionize open-world games" and all they gave us was a FO4-reskin looter-shooter that was half-broken and buggy as hell. Even the story was a bit "meh" to me. I enjoyed Keanu Reeve's inclusion into the story and such, and both Judy and Panam are very well-executed characters, but past that, the game's story doesn't feel alive or rewarding, and neither does the world its set in, either.
I'm sorry, but good graphics don't make a city come to life. NPCs disappearing in the blink of an eye, cars vanishing out of existence, and two of the same exact NPCs standing right next to each other doing the same exact thing isn't exactly... how do I put it? Lively-looking? It reflects very poorly on the world, and makes you feel much less engaged with what you're playing through.
Oh, and understand that I could go on and on about what's wrong with this game, from bugs to AI, to glitchy mechanics and extremely basic dialogue, but I don't nearly have the time to read out the list in full detail. This game is literally the definition of "death by a thousand cuts," as there's no singular problem that can be directly attributed to the reason for the mediocre-ness of this game (aside from poor decisions on CDPR's part, but I'm mainly talking about the game itself anyways).
At least for me, this game was a bunch of unfulfilled promises from CDPR, and I had waited to post this review in the hopes that CDPR would do something beneficial for the game besides bug fixes, but it has been months since release and I'm getting tired of waiting. I'm not pissed or anything, I'm just very, very disappointed with the way this game turned out. CDPR should've waited a few more years.