I just watched season 1, and the most talented designers did not win.
Esther was in a different class. Smart and educated, as a winner her talent would have brought new waves in the couture world.
The judges should have ask and encourage her to continue adding colours and patterns during the competition. She was breaking her fears and restriction to black, and everything she did was perfect.
Not so much for the winner. He showed a lot of confidence in himself, repeat what the judges wanted to hear, but his work did not support the claims. He can send his clothes for sale to Walmart.
Fashion should be art and inspiration.
I wonder if the future show deserves to be seen, or will just be a lesson for " correct attitude is more important than work and talent."