Potential is there and it really was a fun game but so many bugs (like major bugs such as no clipping, flying buildings, cars randomly going crazy, NPCs appearing in random places after phone calls with them, enemies just appearing and disappearing, side missions not activating, random items unable to pick up, ability to cheese and insta kill almost every mission, just to name a few I had), issues with basic mechanics, zero customization, very linear gameplay, and the end game makes no sense. I only harp on the gameplay since it was said to be unique and I have really no hunger to play after the first run. Other than to see the different endings from 100% gameplay save point.
These are all things that could have been fine-tuned to win GOTY, however, based on this terrible release I would keep this at a 3 since it was fun but zero immersion was had with this game since the cut scenes, terrible first person pov, and someone bad VO in the protagonist was lackluster.
However, that being said I do not regret buying this and grinding the hours as it was a fun and different game.