SPOILER ALERT
This game is genuinely a letdown, despite the high hopes I held for it.
First, The gameplay, graphics and sheer detail in this game is astonishing, something that I and many critics Laud it for. The way Ellie (or Abby) interacts can interact with the environment is astonishing, and the attention to detail, as always belies great passion and hard work.
The story, however is littered with gaping plot holes, characters lack depth, and the bittersweet magic of the original has vanished, leaving only a perpetual sour taste, that continues to build into a joyless, bleak and dissatisfying resolution that feels like a cold slap to the face.
Abby is the primary antagonist of the game, a title that she deserves due to her brutal, violent and soulless character. Several of the best characters are unceremoniously killed by her hand, Including Joel, but we are still expected to empathise with her despite her inherent lack of positive attributes.
Abby is horrible not only because of her actions, but her portrayal. After recklessly running into a horde of walkers for no real reason, Abby is saved by Tommy and Joel, (who give her their names for no real reason). They then return to the ski lodge with Abby, where as thanks, she and her band of inconsequential characters blow Joels leg to pieces and beat him to death with a golf club. Joel has no character whatsoever and is used simply as a plot device. Abby later celebrates her cowardly victory in a tasteless sex scene with her (now taken) ex, a scene which serves no purpose other than to further our rapidly growing disgust for her character.
The player is expected to play as Abby, for approximately half the game, and it this point, all motivation to finish the game evaporates, as there is no motivation whatsoever for the player to try and keep her alive.
After much filler and a few more unnecessary character deaths, we reach the ending, where Ellie chooses to leave Abby alive, rendering virtually the entire game pointless, and in the process loses the only things still left to her, being Dina, J.J. and her ability to play the guitar. when compared to the original games' bittersweet and simple ending, TlOU 2 just feels like an
unnecessarily bleak and sour resolution, more like a fizzle than a bang, with Ellie gathering her things and setting off alone, presumably to commit suicide because of how bad the story was.
There are so many more things wrong with the game (not to mention the dirty false advertising) but frankly, it's late and this thing is too long for anyone to read anyway. Suffice to say, TLoU 2 is a passion project let down only by it's immensely frustrating story.