Disclaimer: 2 Stars if you are not a SRK Fan. I am a SRK Fan but I went with only reasonable expectations for this movie based on the Trailer and some of the negative reviews I heard.
Unfortunately, I am sorry to say that the movie was even below my expectations. Box Office collection of Pathaan is a testament to the power of having a worldwide, multilingual release for Stars like SRK, and the importance of spreading positive reviews (paid or from superfans) during the 1st weekend. By the time the real review of the movie is out, it would have easily made big bucks 🤷🏻♀️
I would have given 2 Stars, if not for the following Positives - SRK's strong screen presence & charisma, equally powerful and important roles for John & Deepika, good performances from all main characters, BGM, and some of the hand-to-hand combat scenes.
Dialogues were decent (especially when compared to the pathetic ones in Brahmastra), and there is some comic relief in few scenes from SRK (old movie references) and Salman.
As to the Negatives, it's literally everything else in the movie - outdated story, shoddy screenplay, predictable plot twists, tiring movie tropes (Villain doesn't shoot the Hero but leaves him to die, doesn't throw away detonator, etc.), over the top action sequences (which I would have ignored if not for the blatant disregard to Physics/Logic, and poor CGI), unnecessary exposure of Deepika (songs and seduction scenes are fine but why to show cleavage even in a flight suit or action sequences), childish heist scene, and just the general stupidity of it all.
I really doubt if Pathaan will continue racking in money beyond 1st week.