I'm 100% sure the one star reviews are from people who watched it with their eyes closed and fingers in their ears. Halle Bailey is an amazing singer, her rendition of part of your world reprise gave me chills. Melissa McCarthy bodies Ursula. The father did feel a little flat but the music made me want to dance, especially under the sea (which was colorful and fun, having fish that remind me of folkloric dancers). The storyline is also pretty close to the original, adding one or two things that the close minded audiences tried very hard to ignore. If you're expecting it to be exactly like the first one, don't see it. That is a completely unrealistic expectation. If you, however, are a competent adult who understands some things might be different and love a good Caribbean beat, see it.