Robert Baum

The film is shot and acted beautifully but lacks the driving suspense it's final act demands

Michael Tolkin must've known the show couldn't just be a behind the scenes historical biopic but something else. I loved it. Paramount and Gulf & Western drama plus the endless mafia interference and aggression, interpersonal intrigue, iconic moments from the iconic film, and many surprise performances (Betty for the win!) -- this is the Golden Globes and Emmys show to beat. Direction was jaw dropping (Alan Arkin especially). Writing was precise and always one step ahead of the audience. I absolutely loved the show.

This is one of the most concise, fearless, and wholly entertaining adaptations of any play any time

Everything I wanted in a summer blockbuster. Some impressive visual direction and locations/production design. Really captures the world of New Orleans