Apparently this movie had major production issues such as extensive reshoots, constant rewrites & also it was originally meant to be released in 2018 but was pushed back until this year.
Director Simon Kenberg, who has written & produced, previous X-Men films, attempts to make a better go of the ‘Dark Phoenix’ saga after Brett Rattner’s X-Men: The Last Stand attempted to do the storyline justice, though it wasn’t universally popular with its execution of it.
X-Men: Dark Phoenix definitely has some pacing issues & you could tell the production issues & postponements have somewhat affected it. As a result, it doesn’t even belong in the same conversation at First Class or Days of Future Past, both of which are two of my favourite superhero movies.
However for me it is definitely better than the last film in this prequel series, Apocalypse, as it feels like a human personal story about how Jean Grey is affected by the Phoenix persona. Sophie Turner does an admirable job of portraying the multiple personalities angle for her character.
What also makes this movie work for me is the theme of taking responsibility for your past & facing the consequences. Charles Xavier & Jean themselves being the two best examples that spring to mind. I like that the story dealt more with ethical dilemmas and consequences of decisions made, in particular with how Xavier’s relationship with Jean leads to the main action within the film.
There was one quote that stuck with me:
‘Sometimes, you want to believe that people are something that they are not. By the time you realize who they are, it's too late.’
That quote rings true throughout the film, in particular with how certain characters react to Jean’s actions when the Phoenix is in control.
X-Men: Dark Phoenix definitely lessens the humour of previous movies and I think that suits the overall tone of the story, though I understand if people don’t agree with it.
I want to conclude by saying I more than understand how some people will not like this movie. There are definitely issues such as pacing, which is wonky at the best of times and the quality could definitely have been better.
But in my opinion it is way better than the staggeringly low rating on Rotten Tomatoes as it does at least have more of a focus on the characters than The Last Stand or Apocalypse.
However, I think it’s a good thing the Fox X-Men franchise has ended as the story has definitely run its course. Plus, I’m interested to see if these characters will be introduced into the Marvel Cinematic Universe in the future.
X-Men 1 & 2, First Class, Days of Future Past, The Wolverine & Logan are way superior to Dark Phoenix but I believe that this is better than X-Men Origins: Wolverine, The Last Stand & Apocalypse.
You may disagree but I wanted to stand up for this movie given the amount of negativity it is receiving.