This was just a completely unbelievable story, I gave 4 stars bc i couldn´t stop watching, but this was just nuts. In order to believe this, you´d have to completely suspend all your common sense and logical thinking. It seemed like a pretty obvious attempt to either clear the parents conscience, and probably turn the story more in their favor. I just can´t believe anyone, especially parents to 3 girls could be so gullible and blind. Through the beginning, I tried to believe it, It was a different time, in most small towns like that pedophilia was basically unheard of, so I gave it the benefit of the doubt going in, I hadn´t read any of these reviews and it seemed like an intriguing description. I didn´t make it very far before I found myself asking, Really?! Even in a different time, i´m pretty sure there are people in the 1600s that would have been able to spot those red flags and warning signs. 1.) out of 3 female children, he only wants to spend time alone with one? 2.) He was their neigbor for what, 2 years? Not all their life, or even a long time, like they try to paint the picture. 3.) After the father and the wife has sexual experiences with him, they don´t start questioning the moral integrity of this man (even though they are deeply religious?) 4.) No alarm bells when you hear about your child acting strangely on their trips? 5.) There gone for days and instead of calling the cops she called the FBI? Idk thatś weird to me...I´m not an expert, maybe that´s what you´re supposed to do, but if my child was missing for day I think I´d call the cops, IF as they say they really thought there was nothing illicit going on, it was some kind of mistake, then wouldn´t you at least be trying to call the hospitals or something to see if she´d been injured? I mean i can´t put myself in their shoes on this bc i would never be in that situation, my daughter goes with no one besides my immediate family, and even if by some insane scenario that happened, I would be out looking for her myself within an hour or 2 of her not coming home when she was supposed to, definitely would have called the cops, hospitals, and been driving around looking, not falling asleep wondering where she was as they did in this movie. Idk I could go on but I think you see where I´m going with this. That was all basically prior to the FIRST kidnapping. I think this title is extremely misleading, it didn´t seem like she was abducted from plain sight twice. About halfway into the film, the question popped into my head, ¨These parents are crazy people. Did they agree to let this man take their daughter?" and then he said the exact same thing i was thinking later in court, that they let him take her. he said in exchange for sexual favors, making it seem like it was just a big sex thing they all had going on, you can screw our child if you screw us, or at the very best scenario, the parents were just crazy (not sick like B) and decided their own embarrassment was more important than locking this guy up. So idk, if the parents were in on it or just not the best parents, but no matter what story they try to create through this film, the details they came up with are just too out there.