My pick early on was Peter. I did not like Jed and his ever present guitar from the beginning. He was performing way too much . And for some reason, Hannah was swooning over his music. Bad choice. Bringing the guitar for the proposal almost made me puke. I think of Tyler of a supporter of hers and a close friend. Now Peter, although it took him longer to reveal his feelings, seemed like the genuine article. And sex 4 times in one night! Is she crazy for letting him go? And all the crying she did when she let him go. She should have realized the depth of her feelings for Peter. I would sort of disgusted about how long Hannah put up and excused Luke P. Wonder if Peter and Hannah could still work out.