matt williams

Meh. It was entertaining, but meh. Took too long at first, then rushed a bunch of stuff. Lots of recreating old scenes instead of creating new things.

The modern spin was exceptionally done. The sheer magnitude of the scale of ships/people/planets was intimidating. The casting was done perfectly. However, the main thing that really brought it home was the blade earning, which was not in the original movie but pivotal for Paul's character development in the book. Well done, well done.