In comparison to ALL other movies including Stranger Tides, Dead Men Tell No Tales is a horrific film. For the average movie go-er this movie is just fine; good villian with fun, over the top action. But to those who have religiously watched the other movies this is a disgrace. Firstly it ignores what makes Captain Jack special, his hidden intelligence. In this movie he is instead displayed as a pure idiot who is just lucky. The compass is also treated poorly, it was described that he bought it from Tia Dalma in the second/third movie and now he just gets it as "tribute". The only upside about this movie is Salazar (who according to the now rules of the compass should have been released during At World's End but we do not get into that). The villian is quite good and menancing, a good step up from Blackbeard. All I have to say is that I hope Disney never makes another POTC movie, especially with that after credits scene and no Johnny Depp (bringing back Jones is a cash grab that disregards the complete arch of his character).