I loved this book. I really thought is super engaging, well-written, and exactly what every twilight fan needed. The negative reviews seem to come from people who weren’t fans of series to begin with, meaning it’s not relevant to the rest us. If you loved the original Twilight , you will enjoy this book. It does tend to drag a bit in the middle but picks back up quickly in the end. We get not only see Edward's in point-of-view but the rest of the supporting characters as well. Contradictory to some reviews , it’s not the same book, there’s many moments that we didn’t get to see between Bella and Edward the first time around in this book. The only thing I wish this book had was more scenes with Edward not involving Bella. More moments with just his family or things he enjoys.