I think all of these "best film of all time" should be considered by those who have read the book. Im sure it was a perfect crossover for those with expectations.
While i absolutely loved both movies, i think hype built expectations higher than what i saw.
Not having the read the books, i felt both movies were far too long. The ending was underwhelming and many characters didn't get much screen time versus what id expected.The special effects, cinematography and acting were phenomenal but in no way did i leave the cinema with the same movie appreciation of having seen Gladiator, The Matrix or similar.
Unquestionably worth seeing on the big screen but somewhat ruined by the expectation of what the reviews say.