I saw this movie in a large theater in San Francisco exactly one week after it opened. There were only FOUR of us in attendance. I couldn't believe this, especially in a city with a huge gay audience, many of us who are, yes, of advancing age, but who saw, both in person and in multiple TV performances, this legend with her absolutely astounding voice and unparalleled persona.
Within 10 minutes, I could see why no one was there. This film was absolutely HORRID. People are raving about Zellweger's performance, and I do think she tried valiantly to portray the troubled Judy Garland at the end of her life. But what came across was nothing but a parody, a caricature -- and a bad one at that. What made it worse was Rene's singing, which was nasal, pinched, and nothing even remotely close to Judy, even on a bad night. Why they didn't dub Judy's music was puzzling to me, especially given that Rene was dubbing her own singing, and even that was poorly executed. If she was going to dub, why not do it with Judy's voice to give the new generation of people being introduced to this legend a glimpse into her raw magnetism. If audience members walk away thinking this was what Judy was all about, then they will wonder why she was considered a legend at all.
Added to this was incompetent direction. The scenes were choppy and incoherent. Also, the cast of supporting characters was essentially laughable: especially the young Judy who didn't have an iota of resemblance to her, and with a weird British accent to boot. And the "Liza" was perhaps the most ridiculous. Given her few lines and appearances, certainly the producers could have found someone who at least looked at least 5% like the real Liza: we have numerous drag queens here in San Francisco who could have filled the bill with aplomb.
I have been and always will be a huge fan of Judy Garland, and it saddens me beyond description that this parody will forever sully her magnificent reputation.