Bloody hell. This is my first souls game.
Cons:
1. No tutorial
2. Incentive for defeating a boss is too low sometimes
3. 1st time I finished it, it took around 100 hrs with a bit of exploration.
4. They don't disclose the entire game locations. There are so many interesting quests and locations completely hidden and can't be found until you really look into it.
5. If this your first try, From Software makes it even harder to elude you.
6. The price.
Pros:
1. The bosses, the art, the locations
2. The story: 1st time around I didn't really get it at all. It was just dodging, locking-unlocking an enemy, slash and back up.
3. There's so much to explore.
4. Value for money.