I'll note, this is far from perfect, but i'll give it a 5 star rating cause people are unfairly treating this as something terrible. It's not terrible.
So first, my main problem with the game was the characters. They were really interesting, but it felt like as soon as laura returned, most of the characters became irrelevant. The characters were better than until dawn, but the devs didn't take the chance to have them fully developed by the end, which was really unfortunate. Laura is a great character, but i'm sad the game forgot about most of the characters near the end. Abby and Emma had a section where they give Kaitlyn the silver bullets, and i thought the characters were finally getting developed, but then you start playing as Laura again, shoot the werewolf, and apparently that was it for the game. It felt a bit abrupt, the game was just starting to get it's climax with all the characters, and just as you were getting back into enjoying each characters' scenarios, the game just ends before you know it. They needed at least 10 more final minutes to play as Max, they needed at least 10 more final minutes to play as Emma or Abby, and same goes for Jacob.
The game has a very strong start, but unfortunately by the end of the game it felt like the devs got lazy, it's very disappointing because this game has a lot of improvements over until dawn, but until dawn handled what it had much better. This game had great potential, but they didn't use it the way they did with until dawn.
But I think this game is about on the same level as Until Dawn, there are plenty of things this game did better, just as there are the same amount of things Until Dawn did better. Still excited for another full game like this rather than just another Dark Picture Anthology