Good read till the last chapter . I did not like the way it ended . I thought Lily was going to help Ryle be a better person . Ryle was to be blamed , but Lily was to be blamed too . She was the one who carried memories of her ex into her relationship with Ryle. Ryle was a good man who did some bad things . He needed help. I think Ryle and Lily were good together , and was disappointed it didn’t happen for them in the end .